FARE Act Became Law in New York City on June 11, 2025

By Manhattan Real Estate Tracker, June 13, 2025

The “Fairness in Apartment Rental Expenses Act” or the “FARE” Act has become law in New York City.  This law, also known as “Local Law 119 of 2024”: (1) prohibits landlords from passing on to prospective tenants the fees of landlords’ hired agents (brokers); and (2) requires landlords to explicitly disclose all fees that tenants must pay to rent an apartment before tenants sign a rental agreement.

On June 11, 2025, the FARE ACT statute became operative. The legislation forbids listing agents and other agents employed by the landlord from charging fees to potential tenants. A landlord’s agent represents the landlord in the rental of an apartment. A listing agent publishes apartment listings with the landlord’s permission.

The law allows for landlords to charge a fee as per subdivision 1 of section 238-a of the Real Property Law which limits “the actual cost of the background check and credit check or twenty dollars, whichever is less, and the landlord, lessor, sub-lessor or grantor shall waive the fee or fees if the potential tenant provides a copy of a background check or credit check conducted within the past thirty days.”

A landlord can be liable for violations committed by the landlord’s agent or the listing agent if (1) the landlord’s agent charges a fee to a tenant to rent an apartment; and/or (2) the listing agent charges a fee to a tenant to rent an apartment.

The law prohibits landlords from requiring renters to rent an apartment through a certain agent. Additionally, the law forbids landlords from making tenants hire a dual agent, who serves as both the landlord’s and the tenant’s agent.

No one can condition the rental of an apartment on tenants hiring a broker, including a dual agent. The law prohibits requiring tenants to pay a broker to rent an apartment, even if the broker claims to be a tenant’s broker.  The law allows a tenant to (1) choose to hire their own broker and pay broker fees; and (2) allows brokers to advertise their services to tenants.

With regard to advertising, the law regulates listings of rental apartments: (1) no one can include an unlawful broker fee; and (2) all fees that tenants must pay to rent an apartment must be disclosed in a clear manner. Landlords and their agents/brokers must give tenants a written disclosure of all fees they must pay to the landlord, or any person at the direction of the landlord, to rent an apartment. The fees must include a written description, and the tenant must sign the itemized disclosure before signing a lease. Landlords or their agents must keep the signed disclosure for three years and give a copy to the tenant.

Additional information on the FARE Act can be found at NYC.gov.

Party City to Close All of its Stores

By Manhattan Real Estate Tracker, December 23, 2024

Party City to Close All Stores

Manhattan Real Estate Tracker has learned that 40-year-old party store retailer Party City will be closing all of its stores in the next few months. Party City operates two stores in Manhattan and eight stores in the five boroughs. Several stores in New Jersey will be closing by the end of February.

Barry Litwin, the company CEO said that the company was hurt by stubbornly high inflation that sent costs soaring and deterred consumers from spending. “It’s really important for you to know that we’ve done everything possible that we could to try to avoid this outcome,” Litwin said. Unfortunately, it’s necessary to commence a wind-down process immediately.”

(Google)

The Container Store Files for Chapter 11 Bankruptcy

By Manhattan Real Estate Tracker, December 23, 2024

The Container Store Files for Chapter 11 Bankruptcy

Manhattan Real Estate Tracker has learned that the Container Store has filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. The store at one time had more than 1400 locations and now is down to about 100 locations. There is one store in Manhattan at 629 Sixth Avenue near the Flatiron Building.

The 1970s-founded store of organizing and storage solutions, The Container Store, has declared bankruptcy as a result of growing losses and cash flow issues. At the same time as demand for its products is being strained in a challenging housing market, where skyrocketing prices and high mortgage rates have slowed sales, the Texas company has seen an increase in competition from retailers such as Target and Walmart. The stores will continue to operate as it restructures.

Photo of the Container Store at 629 Sixth Avenue (Google)

FARE Act Passed by New York City Council

By Manhattan Real Estate Tracker, December 18, 2024

FARE Act Passed by New York City Council

The FARE Act, also known as Introduction 360-A, became law on December 14, 2024. Mayor Adams did not sign the law. The new rule forbids landlords from charging potential tenants the fees of brokers they engage, and it will go into force 180 days after it is passed.

The full press release by the City Council can be found here.

Heating and Hot Water Requirements for Apartments in the Five Boroughs of New York City

Heating and Hot Water Requirements for Apartments in the Five Boroughs of New York City

By Manhattan Real Estate Tracker, November 13, 2024

Residential tenants are legally entitled to hot water and heat from building owners. A consistent minimum temperature of 120 degrees Fahrenheit must be maintained for hot water throughout the year. During the “Heat Season,” which runs from October 1 to May 31st, heat must be supplied under the following circumstances:
Day
If the outdoor temperature drops below 55 degrees between the hours of 6:00 am and 10:00 pm, the interior temperature must be at least 68 degrees Fahrenheit.
At night
The inside temperature must be at least 62 degrees Fahrenheit between 10:00 p.m. and 6:00 a.m.

From NYCHPD

Ares Management to Acquire a Large Hell’s Kitchen Residential Building

Ares Management to Acquire a Large Hell’s Kitchen Residential Building

By Manhattan Real Estate Tracker, November 12, 2024

The majority (75%) of 525 West 52nd Street will be purchased by Ares Management. The deal was structured to incorporate an assumed $200 million loan at a below-market rate. This building was designed by Handel Architects. According to the building’s website, the apartments include state-of-the-art appliances, including in-home Bosch washers and dryers, high ceilings, and rooms are framed by oversized windows showcasing city and river views. Current availabilities range from approximately $3600 for a studio to $8000 for a two bedroom. It’s great living in Hell’s Kitchen.

Trader Joe’s Opens in Harlem at 123 West 125th Street

By Manhattan Real Estate Tracker, July 26, 2024

Photo: Crains New York Business

Trader Joes is coming to Harlem at 123 West 125th Street. This will be their first store in Harlem. The store is 18,000 sq. ft. in size and the company said that over 100 employees will be hired. The 125th Street corridor has transformed over the past 10 years into an amazing blend of local and national retail stores and restaurants. Neighbors to this new store include Whole Foods, Marshall’s, Old Navy, Shake Shack, McDonald’s, Bath and Body Works, Chipotle, Wingstop and Checkers.

Trader Joe’s was founded in California in 1967 and has grown to 571 stores nationwide. There are now 10 stores in Manhattan.

Affordable Housing Opening in Midtown’s Garment District

By Manhattan Real Estate Tracker, July 2, 2024

The lottery for a newly constructed 19-story building at 339 West 38th Street is open until August 19, 2024. The Department of Housing Preservation and Development states that the apartments in this building have washers and dryers. There is also a lounge, outdoor terrace, fitness center, ping pong center, bike storage, tenant storage, and conference center in the building. The building will also have a 24-hour lobby attendant and two package rooms. Tenants will pay for electricity including electric cooking and heating, the rent includes hot water. The eligible household income range is $31,612 to $218,010. More information can be found at the HPD website at Lottery Details -Housing Connect (nyc.gov)

Photos of 339 West 38th Street from HPD

American Strategic Investment Company to Sell 9 Times Square for a Big Loss

By Manhattan Real Estate Tracker, June 27, 2024

Manhattan Real Estate Tracker has learned that the financially troubled American Strategic Investment Company (ASIC) has entered into a contract to sell the building at 9 Times Square for $63.5 million. The company will be taking a huge loss on the sale price since according to company records, the property was purchased for $162,291,000 prior to 2015 – a loss of more than $98 million. Formerly New York City Reit trading under the NYC symbol, the company changed the name to American Strategic Investment Company in an effort to purchase property outside of the city. This REIT has been a disaster for investors who have lost a huge amount of their initial investment. The stock went public 2021 and has dropped approximately 90% in value. After paying off the loan, the sale is expected to net only $13.5 million which the company claims will be used to buy other properties outside of Manhattan. The sale price of 9 Times Square reflects how the Midtown office market has plunged since the pandemic resulted in many employees working remotely.

Manhattan Real Estate Tracker spoke with a couple of law firms this week who have shuttered their Manhattan offices giving back large chunks of space to the landlord. Some companies have most of their employees working remotely with only a receptionist and a few conference rooms to meet with clients. Other law firms outside the city in New Jersey and Long Island have also closed offices and are working remotely. The same business model change has also occurred in the insurance industry with many adjusters now working from home.

Michael Anderson, the Chief Executive Officer of ASIC stated, “We expect this sale to generate approximately $13.5 million in net proceeds at closing, which we intend to use to pursue the expanded asset acquisition and diversification strategy into higher yielding assets that was announced last year. Additionally, if completed, we expect that this strategic disposition will strengthen our balance sheet.”

More information on the sale of 9 Times Square can be found on the ASIC website.